The North to South downward gradient in the use of milk
A genetic problem with probably prehistoric consequences
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are three points taken as scientifically "proven"
1) No adult mammal can digest milk (lactose)
2) With one exception: Nomads could stomach milk
Problem: The population in the territory of the western Baltic can digest milk
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------As a rule: All mammals receive mother's milk as ' starting food ', but
after nursing time all mammals lose the ability to digest full milk
and the young denied mothers breast.
( It is Darwin and an enzym LACTASE behind)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
First osmotic problems with mother´s milk. (LACTOSE)
Milk
g /% human cow goat sheep horse reindeer
Water 87.2 87.5 82.7 86.6 90.1 82.8
Carbohydrates 7.0 4.8 6.3 3.9 5.9 5.5
Lipids 4.0 3.7 5.3 3.7 1.5 7.4
Protein 1.5 3.5 4.6 4.2 2.1 3.6
kcal/100 ml 70 66 86 65 43
kJ/100 ml 294 278 361 273 180
-------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------
Problem: The data for water and carbohydrates in milk are biological
constants. After Darwin genetically set optimal by mutation and selection
along millennia of evolution.
The aim 870 ml of water and 70 g carbohydrates in one liter of lactose
No more and no less.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Osmosis
870 ml water a constantWater in biological structures - in or around cell - can flow along an
osmotic gradient only
![]()
hohe Konzentration high
mittlere " middle
Losungsmittel solvent (water)For further understanding of the given hypothesis the physical back-
ground of osmosis is in detail not necessary (I hope so :-) if, then please
google Finally the crucial point to follow the biological problems
Water flows in a body always passively from areas of low osmolarity
into areas of high osmolarity
(e.g.from of 100 mosmol ´uphill´into an area of 600 mosmol )
------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------
Problem I: Sugar (carbohydrates) in milk of mammals is not a normal
sugar, no normal glucose. Milksugar consists of a double molecule.
One glucose becomes connected with one galactose.
One key for understanding evolution of mammals
Problem II Evolution of mammals has to face difficulties in construction.
The relatively high osmotic pressure of 70gr carbohydrates in milk
In blood plasma ~ 1 g glucose / L.
in milk 70 g "
Hypothesis: The osmotic pressure of milk sugar is -after Darwin - optimal,
if 870 ml water flows within a certain time (x-minutes) from plasma water
into the mammary gland,.
no more, no less despite of 70 g carbohydrate in 870 ml water
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The crucial point: The osmotic pressure and thus the "water -drawing force" depends on the number of molecules
dissolved in a liquid , not on the size of
the moleculesProblem I: If carbohydrates in milk would not be a double-molecular lactose
but single glucose and galactose molecules, then the corresponding osmotic pressure would be ~ 450 mosmol.
Could be that such a " high" pressure would draw much more than 870 ml
water into the milk.
Hypothesis: By combining two molecules to one molecule the number of
osmotic effectiv molecules becomes halved and thereby the osmotic pres-
sure of carbohydrates drop by half, allowing to store 70g lactose in 870 ml
water with an osmolarity of 450 : 2 =225 mosmol, supposed to be an optimal
biological value developed by mutation along millennia of evolution accor-
ding to Darwin´
The double-molecul latose is needed to keep an optimal water volume
in milk constant.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lactase
Problem
The double molecule lactose is for mammals ungestable.
To digest milk a spezial baby enzyme is needed
The molecules pass undigested baby´s stomache and enter the small
intestine. Here a special baby-enzyme Lactase split the double-molecule
lactose. Being splitted to glucose and galactose the lactose becomes digestable.
( Thus without lactase no mammals ? )
![]()
So far no biochemistry problems, but In human18 month after birth at the
end of the weaning period
the enzym lactase becomes switched off
???
The common explanation: The digesting system of the young is sufficiently developed
to digest meat, vegetables etc.Thereby no need for a further livelong active Lactase-Enzym .--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mother´s milk being indigestible ?
Problem I: The relatively oversized double-molecule lactose can´t pass
a cell membran , i.e. can´t leave the intestinal. To get digestible this ´large´
double -molecule had to be splitted.
An enzyme (Lactase) in the small instestine parts the double molecule and
glucose and galactose can pass the cell membran and get digested.
After weaning Problem II :After weaning
the Llactase enzyme becomes inactivated and
indigestable lactose passes the stomach and enters
the small intestine. For
baby a problem because it can´t digest
milksugar any longer, thus feeling
ill by ease. (it´s Darwin behind.)
The reason : Milksuger (lactose) passes indigested baby´s steril stomach
and small intestine and enters the following colon.
The " home"of masses of normal germs needed for final digestion. These
germs can digest lactose
(Normally glucose never enters the colon because sugar becomes comp-
letedly digested in the intestine.)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If after weaning bayby´s Lactase enzyme becones inactivated then "70 gr"
lactose enters the colon. The colon germs have active lactase enzyms and
can split and digest the large quantity milk sugar.
A procedure slipping out of control causing flatulence, painful contraction of
muscles and even failure.
Baby begins by experience to dislike milk and step by step becomes adap-
ted to the food of the adults.
The evolution has reached its goal,
The baby feels unwell after drinking and denied mother's breast
Thus the needed emotional mother-infant bonding
becomes ended by the infant
Milk is no more needed. The next pregnancy becomes possible
The number in a group grows
Darwin´s Theory full in action.
The enzym LACTASE is part of a biological timing-
system optimizing the reproduction periods of mammals
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So far in general the biological background of indigestable milksugar and
the reason for Lactase on and lactase off after weaning
As a rule: All mammals receive for a start mother's milk but after nursing
time mammals lose the ability to digest full milk
Optimizing reproduction periods may be the reason
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Problem I: In certain people lactase activity maintaine after weaning.
Problem II: There is in Europe a North to South gradient in lactase activity.
Lactase and prehistoric
Obviously there is a North to South gradient![]()
(worldwide s.P.S)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thus looking for a Northern area where cows may feel good.
Needed a temperate climate with a humid atmosphere,a fertile soil, forested
with deciduous trees and grass areas. Sparsely populated.
Could be the western area of the Baltic Sea
The Central European tundra retreated slowly towards north.
Along the Danube and in Southern France developed first
clear forests. Birch, coniferous trees and hazelbush spread.
The gradually expanding forests in Central Europe forced
reindeer and reindeer hunter to follow the tundra .
The post-magdalénian reindeer hunter knows (? ) or learns that - instead of
hunting - domestication of "milkable-animals" may improve the feeding basis , provided milk is available in sufficient quantity.
Thus the Magdalénian reindeer hunters had to adapt to new living conditions
Bred back Auerochs, instead of reindeers
All along millennia the cultural background of the Magdalénian had been
hunting.Thus no fundamental change was needed. Instead of herded (?) rein-
deers , the Auerochs herded in livestock farming became the fundament of mesolithic, megalithic culturers in the North.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prehistory
Lactase not switched off
Certain human populations have undergone a genetic mutation allowing
Strabo ( Greek historian (30 B.C) indirectly pointed to milkdrinking Norther-
members of these groups to continue consumption of fresh milk live-long
ners with the remark that humans on the British Isles, though they have
much milk do not make cheese . ( For a Greek historian a matter worth to
remark)
He knows that in Greece milk is primarily used for making cheese but not
for drinking . Skytian, Thrakian, Kimmerian, Hyperborean are from view of
a Greek northern 'nomads-. They milk their mares,. drink milk thereby
named "Hippomolgoi "or" Galaktophagio "Sauter) .
Haack
The map of percentages for lactase-pesistence in present Europe. A distinct
line from north-west to south east.
In the North the megalith - funnel cup Culture TrichterbecherkulturThe old question: What became drunk in the cups ?
Notice the small feeding cup. In shape and size used to day in hospitals.
It is assumed in generall that the knowledge to domesticate animals and to
(Baumgärtel)
Sahara, Cattle time Rinderzeit
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
cultivate the soil originated in the Near East and reaching Europe in the 6th -
5th. millenium. If so then a
Problem Adult lactase persistence is highest in those regions where domes-
ticated animals are said to arive last in Europe but -problem- not where
cattle are supposed to have been domsticated first.(sounds a little bit strange how
to ´incorporate´Darwin ? )
Unknown further whether the Cro-Magnon reindeer hunter already could drink
fresh milk of reindeers, being Lactase-persistent ? -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Compareable to the Rickets (blond) the key for understanding the* Lactase-
Problem*is again a genetic adaptation, following Darwin´s Theory. The down-
ward ´milk-drinking´gradient from North to South may be based on a genetic
selection enforced by HUNGER
Hypothesis:
May be that the isolated post-Magdalénean hunter in the North may become
in time cattlel/dairy - farmer and in the run of thousands of years subsisting
more and more entirely on the meat, blood, and at most primarily on the milk
of their herds. The genetic again has to adapt.After weaning the splitting Lactase enzym was not switched off but remained
in full action a life long.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
More to the South milk of sheeps and goats is up to day used primarily not
for drinking but for making cheese .A possible reason: Cheese is almost
free of milk sugar.Thereby no lactase is needed to digest cheese.
Problem solved ? No ! Cheese, consisting primarily of the curd. Tthe semi-
solid substance formed when milk curdles, or coagulates. Curdling occurs
naturally if milk is not used promptly :It sours, forming an acid curd, which
releases whey, a watery fluid (87%) containing the soluble constituents.
1 kg kg milk Caloric value
Lipid 9500 Cal/kg 37gr 351 Cal (x 4.18 J)
Protein 4100 33 135
Milksugar (Lactose) 4100 48 187
-------------
680 kcal Problem: While cheese making the milk sugar remains in the whey. Conse-
quently cheese becomes digestible world wide even for people which lack
the enzym Lactase. But there is a problem for cheese eaters:
By cheese making
up to 25 % of the caloric value of fresh-milk is lost.
Likely that HUNGER caused a genetic selection which enabled at least the
early northern Magdalénean to digest step by step milksugar. Those who could
might survive an otherwise deadly famine.
Mutation and Selection in Darwin´s Theory full in action.The proof of a lifelong active lactase in Northerners supports the view that in
the North milk had been a vitally basic food. If this is true, then the Post-
Magdalenean-Proto-Germans had plentiful reasons to worship the cow
Summing up :All in all: It´s milk behind
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Sweden Denmark Anglo Saxon
------------------ Bronze Age ----------------- 700 ADFacit: The fact that in Europe Northerners almost ´exclusively´ could digest
fresh fluid milk during whole life supports the view, that for biological reasonsThe ancient culture of the northern Megalithic area was based
primarily on cattle/dairy farming
but scarcely on agricultureBenecke, Norbert *Der Mensch und seine Haustiere. (Die Geschichte einer
jahrtausendalten Beziehung. 1994)*
Haack,K, http://www.mcdonald.cam.ac.uk/genetics/khindex.html
Sauter, Herrman *Studien zum Kimmerierproblem* www.kimmerier.de http:
1-milchzucker May 0.4 , July 06*
Index
Next: In the North a culture of ´hunters´ not of farmers
( In the North dairy farmer waiting for learning agriculture * ex oriente* ? )
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
P.S.
Percent of lactose intolerant population:
African Blacks 99 Asian Indians, South Dravidians 97 Nigerians, Yorba & Ibo tribes 99
Filipino 90 Bantus 90 Thais 90
Japanese 85 Taiwanese 85 Indians, American 85
Greek Cypriots 85 Mediterraneans 80 Greenland Eskimos 80
Arabs 78 Ashkenazi Jews 78 Mexicans 75
Turks 72 American Blacks 70 Peruvians 70
Jews 70 Australian aboriginals 70 Maoris, New Zealand 64
Jews, Israeli 58 Samoans, New Zealand 54 Nigerians 20
Finns 18 Europeans, middle 15 Pakistanis, NW Indians 10
New Zealand Europeans 9 American Caucasians 8 Swiss 7
Northern Europeans 5 Danes 2 http://niazi.com/Milk/bitter.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lactose_intolerance (more detailed)
http://benmuse.typepad.com/ben_muse/2007/09/lactose-intoler.html (Historic)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
An onsolved ´hidden´problem
Problem:
For
bones calcium is needed,~ 1000 mg /day.
For ´sole´hunters : Where to get
it ?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Food calcium content http:(german)
mg pro 1000 g
Milk 1230
Joghurt 1230
Curd -cheese ~ 1000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hazelnut 2250
Green cabbage 2100
Fabaceous 560
Rye bread 290
Potatoes 100Apple 50
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Beef 70
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To make a daily requirement of 1000 mg of calcium 1 liter milk or 400 gr
hazelnuts is needed
Problem: What food - calcium was available in the European tundra ?
Beast of prey must break up and "digest" bones to get the needed calcium
Thus reindeer hunters had to be milk-drinker ?
or metabolize bones ?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The striking height of Northerners (~170 cm) could be based on the lifelong biologically optimal nutrition Among others an overplus of calcium.
At least Tacitus wondered about the * hühnenhaften bodies * of the Teutons.
It is not well-known how far milk of reindeers played a role in prehistory.
A nice Google-story:
“ A woman, who had employed a girl fled from Latvia as a house aid and soon
to its fright had to state that the girl neither could deal with the vacuum cleaner,
the washing machine, nor with the different other kitchen devices.
“What you can do?” she asked desperately.The girl radiated full pride and said:
“I can milk a reindeer.” :-
The fat content of reindeer milk is 22%, six times as much as cow's milk. It is the only source of milk for Laplanders in northern Scandinavia, because no other dairy animal can survive in such a cold, hostile environment. It takes two people to milk a reindeer -- one to do the milking and the other to hold the reindeer's horns.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Korea
Milk, Dolmen and Mounds
"Dairy products were introduced into Korea as ‘‘western’’foods in recent decades.The domestic dairy production industry began in earnest in 1962 when South Korea,understate sponsorship, imported dairy cows.The industry,which produced 48,000 tons of raw milk in 1970, has grown to produce 2.5 million tons of raw milk in 2002. http://aic.ucdavis.edu/research/FPopenKordairy.pdf.
"Milk - Nearly 90 percent of South Korea's milk output is consumed fresh.----
(Problem : fresh ? no lactase added
?)
South Korea's dairy industry is a recent development, beginning with the purchase of 2,000 Holsteins from the United States and Canada in 1962.The dairy herd size now (1991)exceeds 500,000 animals, all Holsteins.-----
Growth in milk consumption has averaged about 19 percent annually for
more than a decade. Before the mid-1970's, use of milk and dairy products was very low because of limited production, lower per capital incomes,"http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m3809/is_n63/ai_11174350/pg_6
![]()
![]()
Mound Kyeogsanbak-Do (5.Jh.) . (klick)
“Large Dolmen (stone tombs) are known in large number in Asia, Europe and
North Africa Worldwide estimated to be approximately 50,000 Dolmen. 60%
of all Dolmen are to be found in Korea, therefore it is named as “Kingdom of Dolmen" (translated).
http://www.explorekorea.de/reise/useite_info_d01.htm
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http: Details
Index
Next: In the North a culture of ´hunters´ not of farmers
xx
etr